Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Tampa Criminal Attorney
Free Consultation Call 24/7

If You've Been Arrested in Tampa Bay or Surrounding Areas, We Can Help You Immediately!

Tampa Criminal Attorney > Blog > Juvenile Charges > Juvenile Vandalism Cases In Florida: A Closer Look

Juvenile Vandalism Cases In Florida: A Closer Look


During coronavirus lockdowns, many police departments stopped responding to non-violent disturbance calls, like reports of vandalism. Now that these restrictions have ended, at least for the most part, many departments are going back to the controversial broken windows law enforcement theory.

This theory began gaining popularity in the early 1980s. Proponents insist that low-level issues, such as vandalism, loitering, trespassing, along with code violations, like broken windows, create comfortable environments for criminals. Therefore, vigorous enforcement in the aforementioned areas either drives criminals elsewhere or decreases violent crime. The theory is controversial partly because there is no clear evidence in support of this theory. Furthermore, broken windows enforcement is associated with racial profiling, at least in the minds of many.

As a result, there has been increased enforcement of Section 806.13, which is Florida’s criminal mischief law. A conviction could have severe direct and indirect consequences. These prosecutions have a number of moving parts. Therefore, a Tampa juvenile charges attorney can often successfully resolve these claims, especially if the defendant’s criminal record is otherwise clean.

Elements of the Offense

In Florida, criminal mischief (vandalism) is “willfully and maliciously injures or damages by any means any real or personal property belonging to another, including, but not limited to, the placement of graffiti thereon or other acts of vandalism thereto.”

First, let’s look at the mental elements. “Willfully” usually means “not accidentally.” People willfully underpay their taxes if they omit income streams, fabricate deductions, or do other such things. In the criminal law context, willfully is usually one step above intentionally. That’s the mental element in most criminal cases.

“Maliciously” usually means malice directed at the property’s owner. Tagging property and marking territory arguably do not meet this standard.

So, the mental element could be a defense. Lack of physical evidence is even a better defense in vandalism and most other criminal cases.

Occasionally, security video or an eyewitness catches a defendant in flagrante delicto (in the act, or red-handed). Much more often, however, these prosecutions rely on circumstantial evidence.

Sometimes, an informant gives police investigators information about the offense. Usually, these informants receive leniency in another criminal proceeding in exchange for the information they provide. Many people will say almost anything to save their own skins. Therefore, uncorroborated informer testimony is often unreliable.

Other times, circumstantial evidence leads investigators to a group of suspects, like a gang. But it does not indicate which gang member committed the offense.

Possible Resolutions

Criminal mischief is a nonviolent crime. Therefore, pretrial diversion or deferred disposition is usually available. That’s especially true if the evidence is weak, as outlined above.

Pretrial diversion programs vary in different jurisdictions. Usually, if the defendant pays restitution, stays out of trouble for a few months, and completes some other program requirements, like performing community service, prosecutors dismiss the charges.

Deferred disposition is similar yet different. Deferred disposition is a post-trial dismissal. The defendant pleads guilty or no contest and serves a few months of probation. If the defendant successfully completes community supervision, the judge dismisses the case.

In both situations, the arrest record remains. However, most employers, educational institutions, and other parties only care about convictions. 

Rely on a Dedicated Hillsborough County Attorney

Vandalism is a serious crime in Florida. For a free consultation with an experienced criminal defense lawyer in Tampa, contact the OA Law Firm. After-hours visits are available.



Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
Client Reviews

"I was in the unfortunate situation of having to hire a lawyer for my grandson and since I did not know of anyone that could refer me, I had to rely on my judgement of character and when I sat down in front of Omar, I knew that I had made the right decision. He is a very professional, well versed in the law, knowledgeable young man that takes the time to explain every aspect of your case to you. He returns calls promptly, knows your case inside out and is very punctual in meetings and court hearings. I could not have chosen a better, more qualified lawyer to represent my grandson. He comes highly recommended by me and you will not go wrong in obtaining his services."

- Gloria

"It is with pleasure that we wish to recommend Mr. Omar Abdelghany in his practice as a Criminal Defense Attorney. He was hired in the defense of our son. The defense included more than one offense, which required legal maneuvering to address the issues. Omar's skills came into play in positioning the case, which resulted in a good outcome given the facts at hand."

- Ted

"Lawyer Abdelghany, has been a tremendous blessing and stress reliever, not only to me but also to my family members in need of professional help. He was understanding of my situation and worked with me financially. I am overall grateful for him and would refer all my family and friends to hire him."

- Khalil G.
View More