Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Tampa Criminal Attorney
Free Consultation Call 24/7

If You've Been Arrested in Tampa Bay or Surrounding Areas, We Can Help You Immediately!

Tampa Criminal Attorney > Blog > Criminal Defense > Following the ‘Clues’ in a Homicide Investigation

Following the ‘Clues’ in a Homicide Investigation


Most of us know about being bored in lockdown. Clue (Cluedo in most other countries) was the product of a much earlier lockdown. As he was bored at home during World War II bombing raids, Anthony Pratt drew on Agatha Christie books and murder mystery party games to create Clue. With some variations, the game that was released in 1949 is the same game on store shelves today. In case you’re wondering, Cluedo is a combination of clue and ludo, which is Latin for “I play.”

Players examine clues to deduce who killed who where with what. Law enforcement investigators use basically the same approach to solve homicides and other violent crimes that no one witnessed. The investigation process often identifies a targeted suspect, a fact which a Tampa criminal defense lawyer can use in court. Furthermore, as outlined below, the process itself is deeply flawed. The combination of a pre-selected suspect and a flawed process often leads to inaccurate results.


The list of people with a motive is very long, which is usually why law enforcement investigators begin with this area. The list is so long because, in many cases, investigators confuse intense dislike with a motive for murder.

The 1990s O.J. Simpson “trial of the century” is a good example. Before the murders, Simpson’s ex-wife swore out a restraining order against him. Investigators assumed that since Simpson didn’t get along well with his ex-wife and was physically violent toward her, he had a motive to kill her.

That logical leap might work in civil court, where the burden of proof is only a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not). But the burden of proof is much higher in criminal court. Legally, jurors cannot connect the dots. Prosecutors must connect the dots for them.

It’s no coincidence that investigators focused on Simpson. Investigators usually assume that one spouse harmed another spouse. Truthfully, that’s a good place to start. However, investigators sometimes fixate on suspects, even if there’s little evidence connecting them with the crime. We’ve seen that pattern in some recent high-profile cases in Florida.


Investigators broadly interpret this prong as well. Opportunity usually means the suspect lived in the same area, like the same ZIP code, and knew the victim’s daily routine. Lots of people live in the same ZIP code. Furthermore, most people have very predictable daily schedules. They drop off the kids, go to work, pick up the kids, and go home. You don’t have to be a detective to figure that out.


In the final area, investigators usually try to match the cause of death with an item in the suspect’s possession. Sometimes, the match is straightforward (e.g. a .22 caliber bullet killed the victim and a laboratory matches that bullet with a bullet from the suspect’s gun).

Other times, the match isn’t straightforward. If blunt force trauma killed the victim and the suspect owned a set of golf clubs, that doesn’t mean the golf club was the murder weapon or that the suspect was strong enough to wield the club in such a way.

We should also take a moment to touch on “scientific” evidence in criminal cases. Ballistic and DNA evidence is usually solid. Other such proof, like tire tracks and blood samples, aren’t nearly as reliable.

 Reach Out to a Hard-Working Hillsborough County Attorney

A criminal charge is not the same thing as a criminal conviction. For a free consultation with an experienced criminal defense lawyer in Tampa, contact the OA Law Firm. We routinely handle matters in Pinellas County and nearby jurisdictions.



Facebook Twitter LinkedIn
Client Reviews

"I was in the unfortunate situation of having to hire a lawyer for my grandson and since I did not know of anyone that could refer me, I had to rely on my judgement of character and when I sat down in front of Omar, I knew that I had made the right decision. He is a very professional, well versed in the law, knowledgeable young man that takes the time to explain every aspect of your case to you. He returns calls promptly, knows your case inside out and is very punctual in meetings and court hearings. I could not have chosen a better, more qualified lawyer to represent my grandson. He comes highly recommended by me and you will not go wrong in obtaining his services."

- Gloria

"It is with pleasure that we wish to recommend Mr. Omar Abdelghany in his practice as a Criminal Defense Attorney. He was hired in the defense of our son. The defense included more than one offense, which required legal maneuvering to address the issues. Omar's skills came into play in positioning the case, which resulted in a good outcome given the facts at hand."

- Ted

"Lawyer Abdelghany, has been a tremendous blessing and stress reliever, not only to me but also to my family members in need of professional help. He was understanding of my situation and worked with me financially. I am overall grateful for him and would refer all my family and friends to hire him."

- Khalil G.
View More